Conversations with Tyler

Seamus Murphy on Photographing Patterns Across Cultures

September 3, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • Afghanistan's resilience and potential for progress lie primarily with its people and diaspora, despite persistent external interference and internal challenges like corruption and conflict. 
  • The perceived differences between nations like Russia and the US, and Ireland and Northern Ireland, often stem from shared human experiences of struggle, humor, and cultural identity, rather than solely political or economic factors. 
  • Seamus Murphy's photographic and filmmaking approach emphasizes capturing the human element, the beauty, and the everyday realities of his subjects, often revealing deeper truths beyond initial perceptions or news headlines. 
  • Success in creative fields like photography and cinema hinges more on intrinsic qualities like curiosity, interest, and a genuine love for the subject matter than on technical skills, which are readily learnable and accessible. 
  • While financial necessity may require taking on less fulfilling work, pursuing projects that genuinely ignite passion is crucial for long-term career satisfaction and impactful creative output. 
  • A significant breakthrough in a creative career can stem from documenting an unexpected and personally resonant subject, even if it seems ordinary to those familiar with it. 

Segments

Optimism for Afghanistan
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:04)
  • Key Takeaway: Despite decades of conflict and external interference, the Afghan people’s inherent resilience, love for their country, and the potential of the diaspora offer a basis for optimism.
  • Summary: The conversation begins with an optimistic case for Afghanistan, focusing on the character of its people, their deep love for their country, and the potential contributions of the diaspora. The discussion touches on the country’s strategic location, historical troubles caused by external powers, and the current impotence of people within Afghanistan due to authoritarian rule.
Afghanistan’s Historical Trajectory
Copied to clipboard!
(00:03:20)
  • Key Takeaway: The apparent progress of Afghanistan in the mid-20th century was derailed by the 1979 Islamic Revolution and Soviet invasion, leading to a regression in societal norms and a strategic vulnerability to exploitation.
  • Summary: This segment delves into what went wrong after Afghanistan’s seemingly promising period in the 1960s and 70s. The discussion points to the 1979 events, regional stirrings, and the influence of religious extremism, noting the stark visual contrast between past and present. The impact of foreign intervention and the role of corruption in hindering modernization are also explored.
Taliban Rule and Internal Dynamics
Copied to clipboard!
(00:05:19)
  • Key Takeaway: The future of Taliban rule is uncertain, but internal reform is more likely than external intervention, with younger Taliban members showing dissent against draconian policies like banning girls’ education.
  • Summary: The conversation shifts to the endurance of Taliban rule, with the speaker expressing doubt about external forces intervening unless another major event like 9/11 occurs. The discussion highlights the internal divisions within the Taliban, particularly among younger members who disagree with the leadership’s strict policies, suggesting a potential for internal recalibration.
Photography Challenges in Afghanistan
Copied to clipboard!
(00:10:18)
  • Key Takeaway: Photographing in Afghanistan presents unique challenges due to an ‘inbuilt radar’ for cameras, requiring photographers to work around this sensitivity and engage with subjects to capture natural moments.
  • Summary: This segment focuses on the practicalities of photography in Afghanistan. The speaker describes the difficulty of candid shots due to people’s awareness of cameras and their tendency to react. The discussion also touches on the love for being photographed, which can be both an opportunity and a challenge, and contrasts the current situation with the religious strictures of the Taliban’s first rule in the 1990s.
Irish Identity and Change
Copied to clipboard!
(00:18:27)
  • Key Takeaway: While Ireland has undergone significant economic and social changes, particularly after the Celtic Tiger era, core elements of its identity, such as friendliness and a dark sense of humor, persist, though the influence of the Catholic Church has dramatically waned.
  • Summary: The conversation turns to Ireland, comparing its past friendliness and warmth to Russia. The speaker reflects on the changes brought by the Celtic Tiger and its subsequent crash, suggesting a learned lesson about status and debt. The decline of the Catholic Church’s influence is discussed as a rapid and shocking, yet perhaps inevitable, societal shift.
Visual Similarities: US and Russia
Copied to clipboard!
(00:35:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Despite political animosity, visual and industrial similarities exist between the US and Russia, particularly in their ‘built to last’ aesthetic and the grandness of their design, suggesting a shared industrial heritage.
  • Summary: This segment explores the visual similarities between America and Russia, prompted by the idea that Michigan resembles Russia visually. The discussion highlights a shared ‘staple design’ and industrial aesthetic, where things are built to last. The speaker explains how this idea for a book project emerged from working on separate projects in both countries and observing these parallels.
Working with PJ Harvey
Copied to clipboard!
(00:42:16)
  • Key Takeaway: Collaborating with PJ Harvey on her albums involved translating her musical themes into visual narratives, often through road trips and capturing the essence of the subject matter, such as the legacy of war and colonialism in England.
  • Summary: The discussion details Seamus Murphy’s collaborations with musician PJ Harvey. He explains how his photography from Afghanistan influenced her album ‘Let England Shake,’ leading him to create music films for her. Their subsequent project, ‘Hope Six Demolition Project,’ involved traveling together to places like Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Washington D.C. to inspire her songwriting and his visual work.
Qualities for Creative Success
Copied to clipboard!
(00:48:22)
  • Key Takeaway: Intrinsic qualities like curiosity, interest, and a love for the subject are more critical for success in creative fields than technical skills.
  • Summary: The speaker discusses the essential traits needed for young people entering creative fields like photography and cinema, emphasizing that while hard work and intelligence are important, genuine curiosity and a deep interest in the subject matter are paramount for navigating the competitive landscape.
Career Compromises and Passion
Copied to clipboard!
(00:50:05)
  • Key Takeaway: Balancing passion projects with necessary work for financial stability is a common career reality, but prioritizing passion for significant projects leads to more fulfilling outcomes.
  • Summary: The speaker reflects on a period early in their career where they took on work primarily for financial reasons, acknowledging its necessity but contrasting it with the fulfillment derived from pursuing projects they truly cared about.
The Dublin Pony Story
Copied to clipboard!
(00:51:00)
  • Key Takeaway: Documenting an unusual and personally striking subject, like urban children with ponies in Dublin, can serve as a significant career breakthrough.
  • Summary: The speaker recounts their ‘big breakthrough’ which was a published story in England about young working-class kids in Dublin keeping ponies in their back gardens, an observation that struck them as unique and led to further exploration and publication.
Current and Future Projects
Copied to clipboard!
(00:51:48)
  • Key Takeaway: Long-term documentary projects, like the one on a Kabul family spanning over 30 years, can evolve into deeply personal and impactful films.
  • Summary: The speaker shares details about their current work, including a film in development about a family they met in Kabul in 1994, a project that has spanned decades and involved significant personal loss and resilience, as well as other research for new projects in Ireland.