Fresh Take: Dr. Allison Alford, GOOD DAUGHTERING

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Daughtering is the unrecognized emotional, logistical, and mental labor adult daughters perform to hold families together, often leading to burnout because it is invisible even to the daughter performing it.  Copied to clipboard!
• The antidote to the invisibility and self-gaslighting caused by uncounted daughtering labor is 'narrating daughtering'—verbalizing or writing down the tasks, thoughts, and feelings involved to give credit to the work.  Copied to clipboard!
• Cultural expectations, rather than inherent ability, train women to perform daughtering, and recognizing this training allows daughters to recalibrate the level of involvement and intensity required in any given moment.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Introducing Dr. Allison Alford

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:25)

• Key Takeaway: Dr. Allison Alford is the leading expert on the unspoken role of the adult daughter, focusing on the toll of being a ‘good daughter’.
• Summary: The episode introduces Dr. Allison Alford, author of Good Daughtering, a communications scholar and researcher. Her work focuses on the invisible emotional glue adult daughters provide within families. This labor significantly impacts women’s sense of identity and worth.

Defining Daughtering Labor

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:31)

• Key Takeaway: Daughtering is defined as the emotional, logistical, and mental work adult daughters perform to keep families together, which is often invisible to themselves and others.
• Summary: Daughtering involves active, yet often invisible, emotional, logistical, and mental work aimed at family cohesion. Many women are burnt out by this labor without recognizing they are performing it. Initial denial of performing this work is common until specific tasks are enumerated.

Four Categories of Daughtering

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:09)

• Key Takeaway: Daughtering work is categorized into four types: Doing (visible tasks), Thinking (future planning/worrying), Feeling (emotion labor/smoothing conflict), and Being (identity work representing the parent).
• Summary: The ‘Doing’ work includes visible tasks like planning holidays or making phone calls. ‘Thinking’ work involves managing future logistics, such as saving money for a parent’s future needs. ‘Feeling’ work is emotion labor, like preventing arguments to ease a parent’s stress. ‘Being’ work relates to one’s lifelong identity as a representative of their parents.

Cultural Training and Expectations

Copied to clipboard!

(00:06:01)

• Key Takeaway: Societal norms train women from childhood to perform daughtering, often conflating it with generalized maternal caregiving expectations, leading to the belief that failure to perform means being a ‘bad daughter’.
• Summary: The expectation for women to perform this work is often attributed culturally to women being ‘good at connecting,’ ignoring the lifelong training involved. This training leads to the fear that not showing up as expected will cause parental unhappiness and judgment. This burden is often confused with broader maternal expectations to provide care constantly.

Qualitative Research Method

Copied to clipboard!

(00:10:33)

• Key Takeaway: Qualitative research, by avoiding a priori assumptions, reveals patterns in what participants fail to name or notice, giving language to invisible labor like daughtering.
• Summary: Qualitative research involves observing situations without pre-existing hypotheses to discover what is truly occurring. Dr. Alford noticed what interviewees didn’t say or lacked language for, revealing patterns of invisible work. Naming this unnamed labor is the first step toward shifting mindsets and creating change.

Most Common Complaint Heard

Copied to clipboard!

(00:17:18)

• Key Takeaway: The most frequent complaint from daughters is, ‘My mom doesn’t know me,’ stemming from a communication disconnect where daughters internalize pain to spare their parents.
• Summary: Daughters often feel unseen or misunderstood by their parents because they withhold their own pain or needs to prevent parental distress. This martyr-like assumption of burden leads to burnout and withdrawal, breaking down the family system. The core issue is a lack of clear communication about the daughtering experience.

The Antidote: Narrating Daughtering

Copied to clipboard!

(00:22:04)

• Key Takeaway: The antidote to ignoring unpaid labor is ’narrating daughtering’—verbalizing what is being done, thought about, and where resources are spent—to give credit to the work, starting with self-credit.
• Summary: When labor is invisible, it is ignored and taken for granted, leading to self-doubt about worthiness. Narrating involves stating aloud, ‘This is what I did as a daughter today,’ which allows for re-examination of one’s own thoughts and actions. Saying things out loud begins the process of giving credit to the effort expended.

Performing Family and Visibility

Copied to clipboard!

(00:25:28)

• Key Takeaway: Family cohesion involves ‘performing family,’ meaning visible actions like organizing a special event (like a snow day setup) help make labor visible, but this shouldn’t overshadow necessary, less visible daily daughtering.
• Summary: Visible acts, like organizing a complex family photo shoot or elaborate snow day, serve as performances that allow others to see the effort involved in creating family memories. However, the daily, less visible daughtering tasks, like routine check-in calls, matter just as much and should not require a ’ticker-tape parade’ to be validated.

Calibrating Involvement and Resources

Copied to clipboard!

(00:37:37)

• Key Takeaway: Daughters must calibrate their level of involvement based on their current resources and the specific need of the moment, recognizing that daughtering is not solely the responsibility of the closest or female child.
• Summary: Research shows that caregiving often falls to the closest sibling or the one with economic advantage, not automatically the daughter. It is acceptable to assess one’s ‘battery level’ before agreeing to a task, such as an hour-long weekly call or emergency home repairs. This reframes daughtering from an identity obligation to a manageable project.

Final Takeaways and Book Goals

Copied to clipboard!

(00:45:09)

• Key Takeaway: The primary goal of Good Daughtering is to help women recognize their extensive labor, give themselves credit, and stop beating themselves up over unattainable standards, while acknowledging that patriarchal expectations place the heaviest weight on daughters.
• Summary: The book aims to provide a resource for women to realize how much daughtering they already perform, leading to self-compassion. It is important to note that while sons also perform caregiving (‘sunning’), the cultural expectation and weight of this labor disproportionately fall on women due to patriarchal norms. The book offers scripts for difficult conversations about setting boundaries.