Gregg Renfrew Is Making Counter Moves in Clean Beauty

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Gregg Renfrew experienced an identity collapse after losing control of Beautycounter, leading to a journey of decoupling self-worth from business success.  Copied to clipboard!
• The sale of Beautycounter to a private equity firm (Carlisle) ultimately failed due to a clash between the founder's community-driven model and the new CEO's old-school, transactional corporate approach.  Copied to clipboard!
• Renfrew bought back Beautycounter out of foreclosure within 48 hours, only to realize the business was too broken to sustain, leading to the difficult decision to shut it down completely to allow for a potential rebirth as 'Counter'.  Copied to clipboard!
• Consumers must vote with their wallets and be highly skeptical of beauty industry marketing, as terms like "clean" or "all natural" often exploit regulatory loopholes, such as the undisclosed ingredients within 'fragrance.'  Copied to clipboard!
• The burden of proof for product safety is inverted in the US, where chemicals are assumed safe until proven harmful, necessitating consumer caution regarding the tens of thousands of untested chemicals in commerce.  Copied to clipboard!
• Gregg Renfrew's relaunch of her brand as Counter emphasizes rebuilding trust through radical honesty, focusing on a community-based commerce model that prioritizes mission and personal empowerment over the team-building structures that led to issues in the previous Beautycounter model.  Copied to clipboard!
• True clean beauty requires comprehensive, hard work that extends beyond ingredient lists to include packaging integrity and ethical sourcing practices.  Copied to clipboard!
• Gregg Renfrew's commitment to 'Counter' reflects a deep personal care for people's health, necessitating a difficult but necessary approach to business.  Copied to clipboard!
• The host praises Gregg Renfrew's courage for pursuing this challenging path after significant professional upheaval, viewing it as a testament to her character.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Rich Roll Show Update

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:00)

• Key Takeaway: Rich Roll is refocusing the podcast mission in January toward wisdom relevant to self-actualization to better filter noise.
• Summary: Rich Roll provided a brief update on his healing back injury, noting he has resumed indoor cycling and swimming. He reflected on attending the Eudaimonia conference and feeling overwhelmed by the noise in the wellness industrial complex. Starting in January, the show will experiment with a tighter focus on self-actualization to serve as a better signal.

Todd Marinovich Episode Reflection

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:21)

• Key Takeaway: Addiction requires creating a non-judgmental space for those struggling, as demonstrated by the palpable pain in the Todd Marinovich conversation.
• Summary: Rich Roll addressed the previous episode featuring Todd Marinovich, noting it differed from typical addict interviews because Marinovich was still actively struggling. He felt compelled to lead the conversation and articulate parts of Marinovich’s story due to his difficulty in speaking clearly. The key lesson learned was the necessity of engaging with compassion and listening without giving advice when someone is deep in the grip of addiction.

Sponsor Introductions

Copied to clipboard!

(00:05:02)

• Key Takeaway: Go Brewing is highlighted as a rapidly growing non-alcoholic beer brand committed to handcrafted, small-batch quality.
• Summary: The first sponsor mentioned is Go Brewing, founded by Joe Chura, which focuses on high-quality, non-alcoholic beers without added sugars. Seed’s DSO1 probiotic is promoted as a daily ritual supported by clinical studies showing it increases good gut bacteria by 400% and supports overall body health.

Beautycounter Sale and CEO Ousting

Copied to clipboard!

(00:08:19)

• Key Takeaway: Gregg Renfrew sold Beautycounter for a billion-dollar valuation in May 2021, but was removed as CEO six months later when post-pandemic sales dipped.
• Summary: Renfrew detailed the sale of Beautycounter to a private equity firm, Carlisle, with the goal of positioning the company for an IPO while she remained CEO. Following the summer post-pandemic shift where consumer spending moved away from cosmetics, the business stumbled, leading Carlisle to replace her with an ‘old school beauty’ operator in early 2022.

Conflict with New CEO

Copied to clipboard!

(00:16:25)

• Key Takeaway: The new CEO’s arrogance and immediate dismissal of Renfrew’s institutional knowledge and community role doomed the post-acquisition strategy.
• Summary: The new CEO, hired in early 2022, immediately signaled he did not want Renfrew involved, despite initial agreements suggesting she would retain control over the mission and community. Renfrew notes the CEO’s decision to pursue a massive rollout with Ulta and rearrange the commission structure without proper notice alienated the core sales force.

Commission Structure Misstep

Copied to clipboard!

(00:19:49)

• Key Takeaway: While compensation needed adjustment, the new CEO failed by implementing changes abruptly without the year-long notice and co-creation process Renfrew previously used successfully.
• Summary: Renfrew agreed the commission structure needed modification to democratize opportunity, but strongly advised against immediate changes. The abrupt implementation, unlike the previous radical change which included a year’s notice and co-creation with leaders, caused an immediate loss of trust among the sales partners.

Foreclosure and Buying Back Company

Copied to clipboard!

(00:28:46)

• Key Takeaway: After Carlisle shut down Beautycounter due to breached debt covenants, a Bank of America representative facilitated Renfrew buying the company back from foreclosure in 48 hours.
• Summary: The accumulation of poor decisions led to the company entering foreclosure, resulting in the evaporation of $700 million in equity for Carlisle, who recouped nothing. Renfrew was given an extraordinary opportunity by the banks to purchase the asset for a very small amount, which she executed over a frantic two-day period.

The Hardest Decision: Shutting Down

Copied to clipboard!

(00:32:52)

• Key Takeaway: To save the company’s future viability, Renfrew had to fire all employees without severance immediately after buying it back, an action that caused intense public backlash.
• Summary: Upon purchasing the company, Renfrew realized there was no cash left to fund operations, forcing her to fire nearly everyone, which resulted in scathing public criticism. Inspired by advice to let a past relationship ‘completely die’ for a chance at rebirth, she decided to shut the company down on May 1st, 2024, to allow for a true reinvention.

Identity Crisis and Soul Searching

Copied to clipboard!

(00:44:21)

• Key Takeaway: Losing her CEO role triggered an existential crisis for Renfrew, forcing her to decouple her identity from her entrepreneurial success.
• Summary: Renfrew felt she no longer belonged after being ousted, questioning who she was without Beautycounter and the title of successful entrepreneur. She spent time in soul searching, energy work, and reading, eventually realizing she needed to stop being angry and focus on her core values: empowering women and improving health.

Reimagining the Brand as Counter

Copied to clipboard!

(00:49:07)

• Key Takeaway: Renfrew chose to launch a completely new entity, ‘Counter,’ rather than a ‘Beautycounter 2.0,’ to reflect the changed world and her own evolution as a leader.
• Summary: She determined that simply relaunching Beautycounter would be insufficient; the world and she herself had changed since 2010. Dropping ‘Beauty’ from the name was intentional, as the essence of the mission is to go ‘counter’ to industry norms, setting a new, higher standard for what ‘clean’ truly means.

Advocacy and Industry Loopholes

Copied to clipboard!

(00:53:38)

• Key Takeaway: The fragrance loophole remains a major legislative challenge, protecting offensive chemicals that mimic the endocrine system.
• Summary: Since the passage of MOCRA (Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act), the focus has shifted to business advocacy alongside legislative efforts. Retailers are now defining ‘clean’ inconsistently, leading to consumer confusion and ‘clean washing.’ Renfrew plans to build a coalition of companies to set a unified, high standard for clean products.

Consumer Education on Toxicity

Copied to clipboard!

(00:59:37)

• Key Takeaway: Consumers must understand that the beauty industry’s claims about aging are often ‘bullshit’ designed solely to sell products, and they vote with their wallets.
• Summary: Renfrew stresses that consumers need information without fear-mongering to make informed choices, and that financial success in clean beauty pressures legacy companies to adapt. She explicitly states that wrinkles are a natural part of aging, not a problem that any cream can solve, and that the industry thrives on creating problems to sell solutions.

Consumer Power and Beauty Secrets

Copied to clipboard!

(01:00:29)

• Key Takeaway: Consumers vote with their wallets, and the beauty industry perpetuates the myth that aging signs like wrinkles are problems to sell products.
• Summary: Consumers have a voice through purchasing decisions, which is as important as voting in elections. The speaker asserts that ‘beauty secrets are bullshit’ because wrinkles are a natural part of aging, not a problem the industry needs to solve. Consumers should not believe labels claiming ‘all natural’ or ‘clean’ without doing their own research due to creative and misleading descriptors.

Toxic Loopholes and Ingredient Awareness

Copied to clipboard!

(01:02:21)

• Key Takeaway: The beauty industry exploits loopholes, such as claiming ‘preservative free’ when raw materials were preserved beforehand, and consumers should prioritize shopping fragrance-free.
• Summary: Products labeled ‘preservative free’ can still contain preservatives if the raw materials were treated before formulation, exploiting regulatory gaps. Common chemicals of concern include parabens, EDTA, PEGs, and formaldehyde (which appears under other names). Shopping fragrance-free is the single most practical step consumers can take to avoid undisclosed chemicals like phthalates.

Regulatory Failures and Consumer Trust

Copied to clipboard!

(01:04:07)

• Key Takeaway: Less than 10% of chemicals introduced into commerce have been tested for human health safety, creating a ‘Wild West’ environment where consumers must err on the side of caution.
• Summary: The regulatory environment means consumers often operate under a reflexive trust that products are vetted, which is often untrue for the vast majority of chemicals used. Skin is the largest organ, and chemical absorption may have long-term impacts that are not immediately visible as a rash. The presumption of safety until proven harmful forces consumers to be proactive about what they put on their bodies.

Rebuilding Trust and Counter’s Model

Copied to clipboard!

(01:06:17)

• Key Takeaway: Counter utilizes community-based commerce to rebuild trust by empowering women with information, leveraging trusted peer-to-peer sharing over traditional marketing.
• Summary: The decision to incorporate community-based commerce is rooted in the belief that people trust their friends, arming women with basic information to help others make informed choices. Rebuilding trust after the previous company’s failure requires slow, honest storytelling and actions that demonstrate commitment to the mission. Over 15,000 women have rejoined, believing in the commitment to ‘walk the walk again.’

Counter’s Business Model Adjustments

Copied to clipboard!

(01:10:06)

• Key Takeaway: Counter’s new model eliminates team building to prevent the accumulation of passive income, focusing instead on individual representation and personalized remuneration based on diverse motivations.
• Summary: The new model differs by not allowing team building, addressing the issue where some individuals benefited from others’ labor without actively working. The speaker defends MLMs generally but notes the previous structure allowed non-performers to collect commissions, which Counter is correcting by democratizing payouts. The company is researching personalized compensation beyond sales percentages, recognizing that many join for mission, advocacy, or community, not just money.

Leadership Lessons from Failure

Copied to clipboard!

(01:19:02)

• Key Takeaway: Effective leadership requires leading from a less emotional, depersonalized state, coupled with radical transparency and deep gratitude toward all stakeholders.
• Summary: The speaker learned to lead from a calmer, more rational place, recognizing that emotional reactions do not change the facts of a business failure. Acknowledging the debt of gratitude owed to partners, employees, and customers who endured the previous company’s collapse is crucial for earning back trust. Leading with gratitude and respect prevents the arrogance that can derail a business, as the core of any business is people.

Navigating Vendor and Customer Fallout

Copied to clipboard!

(01:22:26)

• Key Takeaway: Reassembling the business required difficult, honest conversations with vendors and former representatives, often involving asking them to take a second chance despite mutual financial losses.
• Summary: Conversations with vendors were consistent: acknowledging the ‘shitty situation’ not of their making and asking them to take a chance again, promising to work closely with a smaller, essential group. Conversations with former brand representatives were harder because they were personal, involving people who lost income and identity when the business dissolved. Honesty, even when painful, allowed some people to find forgiveness and support.

Current Business Challenges

Copied to clipboard!

(01:25:15)

• Key Takeaway: Major hurdles for Counter include intense competition from brands falsely claiming ‘clean’ status, navigating the implications of AI for sustainability, and slowly winning back disillusioned former supporters.
• Summary: The market is saturated with beauty brands claiming to be clean, forcing Counter to constantly redefine its value proposition against competitors who are not genuinely clean. The company is grappling with the environmental impact of AI technology, which conflicts with their sustainability roots. The slow process of earning back the trust of former customers and representatives who lack full context remains a significant, ongoing challenge.

Lessons on Selling and Control

Copied to clipboard!

(01:29:26)

• Key Takeaway: Selling controlling interest in a company means relinquishing control, and founders must be honest about whether they seek cash exit or continued operational autonomy.
• Summary: Founders often mistakenly believe they can sell a controlling stake and still run the business their way; investors protect their investment by imposing their own methods. Entrepreneurs must perform due diligence on potential partners by asking how they handled past crises, prioritizing autonomy over the highest valuation number. Revenue growth should not automatically trump profitability, as profitability provides essential optionality for decision-making.

Future Exit Strategy and Succession

Copied to clipboard!

(01:34:54)

• Key Takeaway: Future exit planning will prioritize understanding downside risks in advance and implementing succession planning, aiming for longevity rather than a rushed exit.
• Summary: If a future sale or IPO occurs, the speaker will be much clearer about the exact terms and carefully examine the downside risks, unlike the previous experience. A key difference will be implementing succession planning, grooming a successor who can lead the brand within a large corporation while the founder remains affiliated with the mission. The current focus is building a business designed for longevity, potentially meaning the company is never sold.

Advice for Female Entrepreneurs

Copied to clipboard!

(01:36:48)

• Key Takeaway: Female entrepreneurs should leverage their high emotional intelligence as an asset, trust their gut instincts over dismissive male board members, and avoid seeking constant external validation.
• Summary: Women are often underestimated in business, but they should view this as an advantage, using their ability to read between the lines to surprise others. The speaker regrets allowing seasoned male board members to overrule her gut instincts based on outdated industry examples, emphasizing the need for founders to confidently execute their vision. Confidence in one’s intuition is vital, especially when facing skepticism from those who rely on past successes in different eras.

Practical Clean Beauty Education

Copied to clipboard!

(01:47:34)

• Key Takeaway: Consumers should avoid fragrance-free products to bypass undisclosed chemicals like phthalates and be wary of spray sunscreens containing oxybenzone or avobenzone due to environmental and health risks.
• Summary: The ’never list’ includes ingredients like PEGs, parabens, and EDTA, but the most practical step is choosing fragrance-free products because fragrance ingredients are protected as trade secrets. Spray sunscreens containing avobenzone or oxybenzone harm coral reefs and are considered harmful to human health, despite some labels claiming ‘reef safe.’ Consumers can use resources like the Environmental Working Group’s Skin Deep Database to research product safety.

Advocacy and Personal Balance

Copied to clipboard!

(01:50:49)

• Key Takeaway: Future advocacy efforts will target the fragrance loophole and supply chain transparency, while the founder now prioritizes non-negotiable self-care and family time over business demands.
• Summary: The speaker intends to continue advocating for modernizing cosmetic regulations, specifically focusing on the fragrance loophole and lack of supply chain transparency, such as undisclosed pre-preservation of ingredients. The founder now treats exercise, sleep, and family vacations as non-negotiables, refusing to let business demands compromise personal well-being, a balance she struggled to maintain previously. Building a business that lasts requires recognizing that success is not guaranteed and requires continuous, humble effort.

Counter Website and Ethos

Copied to clipboard!

(01:54:59)

• Key Takeaway: The website for Gregg Renfrew’s new venture, Counter, successfully evokes the brand’s clean ethos.
• Summary: The website for Gregg Renfrew’s new company is confirmed to be counter.com. The design effectively communicates the brand’s commitment to being genuinely clean. This visual representation aligns with the company’s core values.

Defining Real Clean Beauty

Copied to clipboard!

(01:55:13)

• Key Takeaway: Authentic clean beauty demands complex, comprehensive effort beyond simple ingredient exclusion, encompassing packaging safety and ethical sourcing.
• Summary: Achieving real clean beauty is acknowledged as extremely hard, complex, and comprehensive work. This effort includes ensuring packaging does not leach toxins back into products. Furthermore, it requires ethically and responsibly sourcing ingredients, including verifying the safety of workers during crop harvesting.

Courage and Character Acknowledgment

Copied to clipboard!

(01:55:47)

• Key Takeaway: The host recognizes Gregg Renfrew’s endeavor with Counter as an act requiring significant courage, reflecting positively on her character.
• Summary: The host expresses pride in Gregg Renfrew’s current work, noting she did not have to undertake this challenge. Continuing forward with this mission demonstrates significant character. The conversation concludes with mutual appreciation between the guest and the host.

Podcast Wrap-up and Support

Copied to clipboard!

(01:56:04)

• Key Takeaway: Listeners are directed to richroll.com for episode resources, sponsor discounts, and ways to support the podcast through subscriptions and sharing.
• Summary: All episode details, links, and resources are available on richroll.com. Listeners can support the show by subscribing on major platforms and leaving reviews, which is described as the easiest and most impactful free action. Sponsors can be supported via richroll.com/slash sponsors, and a newsletter is available for updates.