How I Built This with Guy Raz

Advice Line with Stacy Madison of Stacy’s Pita Chips

October 16, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • When pivoting from a primary business (like the pita sandwich cart) to a side project (the pita chips), listen closely to customer demand and prove the concept externally before fully committing to the new direction. 
  • For new product categories or unknown spirits (like Pisco), prioritize building brand awareness (e.g., Suyo) to become the spearhead, as consumers rarely champion a category without a strong brand to rally behind. 
  • For established heritage brands (like Stuckey's), while maintaining product integrity is crucial, strategic 'weird' marketing moves or leaning into unique product attributes (like pecans as a native protein source) can attract new, younger demographics. 

Segments

Stacy’s Post-Pita Ventures
Copied to clipboard!
(00:03:29)
  • Key Takeaway: Entrepreneurial burnout can result from scaling a passion project (like an energy bar) too quickly, especially when facing unexpected external crises like a pandemic.
  • Summary: Stacy Madison spent time raising her children after selling Stacy’s Pita Chips. She pursued a passion project with Stacy’s juice bar, which aligned with her original healthy sandwich concept. An energy bar venture, initially popular locally, burned her out after scaling to 1,200 stores and incurring significant financial loss during the pandemic.
Pivoting from Side Hustle
Copied to clipboard!
(00:06:15)
  • Key Takeaway: The true business opportunity is often revealed when customer demand for a free side item (like pita chips) outweighs the focus of the main operation (pita sandwiches).
  • Summary: The decision to focus on pita chips came when customer chatter and requests for bulk bags indicated overwhelming demand for the free samples. Stacy Madison advises proving out a concept outside the initial location by taking samples to stores and talking to retailers before making a full pivot.
Modern Marketing Necessity
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:57)
  • Key Takeaway: Starting a business today requires engaging on current social media platforms to reach the target generation, unlike the location-based marketing of the 1990s.
  • Summary: If starting the pita cart today, Stacy Madison believes it would be necessary to adopt current platforms like Instagram or TikTok to reach consumers. It is hard to reach people now without getting on their specific microphone.
Dough Guy: Community to Brand
Copied to clipboard!
(00:09:52)
  • Key Takeaway: Leveraging a highly engaged social media community (130k followers) built around a specific niche (home pizza making) provides the foundation for product sales (pizza steel).
  • Summary: Sam Kagle founded Dough Guy, selling pizza steels to enable restaurant-quality pizza in home ovens, capitalizing on his Instagram following. His brand differentiation lies in simplifying pizza making and showing anyone can achieve restaurant quality. He seeks advice on scaling the brand beyond his personal presence.
Pizza Steel Value Proposition
Copied to clipboard!
(00:13:38)
  • Key Takeaway: A pizza steel offers superior heat transfer and retention compared to a pizza stone, allowing home ovens (max 550°F) to achieve better charring than stones can.
  • Summary: The pizza steel is cheaper and more convenient than specialized pizza ovens, making it accessible for apartment dwellers. Unlike stones, the steel preheats to 550+ degrees and retains heat well, transferring it effectively to the dough for high-quality pizza.
Suyo Pisco: Category vs. Brand
Copied to clipboard!
(00:27:21)
  • Key Takeaway: When introducing an unknown spirit category (Pisco), marketing efforts should lead with the specific brand (Suyo) rather than leading with the category education.
  • Summary: Alex Hildebrandt’s Suyo Pisco is a single-origin spirit from Peru, facing the challenge of consumer unfamiliarity with the Pisco category. The advice suggests flipping the script: consumers discover Pisco through Suyo, making the brand the tip of the spear, similar to how Patron defined tequila for many U.S. consumers.
Pisco Cocktail Strategy
Copied to clipboard!
(00:29:09)
  • Key Takeaway: To encourage home adoption and approachability, focus marketing on simple, few-ingredient cocktails (like the Pisco Punch or Pisco Tonic) over complex, traditional drinks like the Pisco Sour.
  • Summary: Suyo leans away from the Pisco Sour because its egg white component makes it complicated for home bartenders. They promote the Pisco Punch (Pisco, pineapple, lime) and the Pisco Tonic, noting the tonic’s connection to Peruvian quinine offers a unique storytelling angle.
Stuckey’s: Reviving Heritage
Copied to clipboard!
(00:37:57)
  • Key Takeaway: A 88-year-old roadside retail chain (Stuckey’s) was successfully reinvented by pivoting away from the failing gas station model to focus solely on its core, high-quality pecan snacks and candies.
  • Summary: Stephanie Stuckey bought the struggling Stuckey’s brand, which once had 370 roadside stores, for $500,000. She pivoted the business to focus on manufacturing pecan snacks and candies in-house, growing sales from $2 million to $10 million across 4,000 doors.
Stuckey’s Marketing Focus
Copied to clipboard!
(00:45:23)
  • Key Takeaway: While pursuing younger demographics is important for growth, established brands should initially double down on their existing, loyal, older customer base that recognizes the brand’s heritage.
  • Summary: Stacey Madison advised Stephanie Stuckey to flood the existing older population who recognizes the brand, as they are the current core buyers. Guy Raz suggested balancing this by leaning into the brand’s history, positioning pecans as ‘America’s first protein bar’ to attract new consumers while maintaining product integrity.