Smosh Reads Reddit Stories

Valentine's Day Special | Reading Reddit Stories

February 14, 2026

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The first Reddit story revealed that the actor's initial concerns about his girlfriend dating him for his minor celebrity status were resolved when they communicated, leading to them becoming an official couple. 
  • The second story highlighted an alarming situation where a nesting partner was attempting to simulate lactation for protein savings, which the hosts and commenters strongly condemned as a massive red flag and a violation of consent. 
  • The third story involved a husband's excessive financial and time support for a pregnant coworker, which was later confirmed to be due to him being the father, leading the OP to immediately seek divorce counsel. 
  • Insecurity and past trauma can cause significant overreactions in new relationships, as demonstrated by the OP who was ultimately broken up with due to her paranoia about a gift from her boyfriend's sister-in-law. 
  • A seemingly minor offense, like sending a poop sticker, can trigger an extreme, disproportionate reaction in a partner if underlying issues or insecurities are present, leading to a breakup. 
  • The hosts highlighted the importance of emotional maturity and direct communication, contrasting the toxic influence of the insecure OP's family with the compassionate advice offered by the sister-in-law. 

Segments

Celebrity Dating Insecurities
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:30)
  • Key Takeaway: A supporting actor worries his girlfriend is attracted to his character, highlighting the common struggle of feeling seen for oneself versus one’s status.
  • Summary: The initial Reddit story detailed a 27-year-old actor’s paranoia that his new girlfriend was only interested in him due to his minor celebrity status on a sitcom. Specific concerns included her referring to him as his character and posting about him with the hashtag #celeb_girlfriend. The OP sought advice on how to discern genuine attraction from attraction based on fame or potential career leverage.
Partner’s Lactation Fetish
Copied to clipboard!
(00:21:30)
  • Key Takeaway: A 19-year-old woman’s partner is attempting to force lactation while playing baby crying sounds, revealing a concerning fetish and disregard for consent.
  • Summary: The second story involved a 19-year-old woman whose 20-year-old partner was stimulating her nipples while playing baby crying sounds, claiming it was to save money on protein milk. When she asked him to stop, he became angry, arguing it was easier for women and that she wasn’t being frugal. The situation escalated when he bought her lactation crackers, confirming the behavior was intentional and non-consensual.
Husband’s Suspicious Support for Coworker
Copied to clipboard!
(00:27:32)
  • Key Takeaway: A husband’s extreme financial and personal support for a pregnant coworker, including attending OBGYN appointments, was confirmed to be because he is the baby’s father.
  • Summary: The third poster was uncomfortable with her husband giving thousands of dollars and extensive personal time to a pregnant coworker whose baby’s father was supposedly out of the picture. The husband gaslit her, accusing her of being selfish and jealous when she questioned the spending and his attendance at her OBGYN appointments. The update confirmed the husband was the father, had been lying, and the OP immediately began divorce proceedings.
Girlfriend’s Celebrity Crush Text
Copied to clipboard!
(00:41:20)
  • Key Takeaway: A girlfriend sent a text expressing regret that a celebrity (‘Mr. Beast’) got engaged before she could date him, causing her partner to question the respect in their relationship.
  • Summary: The fourth story involved a 24-year-old man whose girlfriend texted him expressing intense regret that ‘Mr. Beast’ got engaged, stating she wished she had met him first. The girlfriend rationalized that it was acceptable because the crush was a famous, unattainable celebrity, but the OP felt disrespected as she had previously discussed marriage with him. The hosts noted that while celebrity crushes are common, expressing a wish to be with them while in a committed relationship is unusual.
Sister-in-Law’s Special Gift
Copied to clipboard!
(00:46:56)
  • Key Takeaway: A girlfriend felt insecure after her boyfriend’s sister-in-law made an elaborate, personal plushie gift only for the boyfriend, excluding her own husband.
  • Summary: The final segment detailed a 26-year-old woman’s anxiety over her boyfriend receiving a high-quality, handmade plushie from his sister-in-law, noting that the sister-in-law’s husband (her brother-in-law) received nothing. The boyfriend dismissed her concerns, stating the sister-in-law was always closer to him, and refused to return the gift. Commenters suggested the OP might be overthinking it, possibly due to insecurity or the possibility the sister-in-law was running out of time to make gifts for others.
Insecurity and Family Dynamics
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:15)
  • Key Takeaway: Past relationship triggers can manifest as current relationship insecurities, leading to misinterpretations of simple actions.
  • Summary: One host shared an anecdote where a friend’s reaction to stolen shirts was rooted in past infidelity triggers. The discussion concluded that the OP in the Reddit story was likely projecting trauma onto a situation involving a gift from a brother-in-law, highlighting how insecurity can cloud judgment.
Sister-in-Law Confrontation and Breakup
Copied to clipboard!
(00:55:00)
  • Key Takeaway: The OP’s escalating insecurity led to a confrontation with the sister-in-law, which ultimately resulted in the boyfriend ending the six-month relationship.
  • Summary: The OP updated that her boyfriend became frustrated with her behavior regarding the gift and her subsequent jealousy about him visiting his brother’s house alone. The sister-in-law proactively met the OP for coffee, offering advice about insecurity, but the OP’s final outburst about divorce caused the sister-in-law to suggest the OP needed self-work, leading to the breakup.
Toxic Family Influence
Copied to clipboard!
(01:00:38)
  • Key Takeaway: Toxic family members can reinforce negative self-perceptions, preventing an individual from recognizing valid external advice.
  • Summary: The hosts noted that the OP’s decision to write the update, despite the sister-in-law’s clear advice, stemmed from seeking validation from her mother and sister, who perpetuated the toxic idea that the boyfriend left for the sister-in-law.
TIFU: Compliment Backfires
Copied to clipboard!
(01:04:55)
  • Key Takeaway: Joking about a partner’s outfit looking better on a parent, especially when the item is a hand-me-down from that parent, can cause immediate social embarrassment.
  • Summary: A husband complimented his wife’s appearance in a shirt, joking it would look better on the floor later, only to discover the shirt was a gift from his mother. The situation escalated when his children and mother joined in teasing him about his comment regarding his wife wearing his mother’s clothing.
Poop Sticker Breakup
Copied to clipboard!
(01:11:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Extreme, non-communicative overreactions to perceived slights, especially when rooted in external peer pressure, are grounds for ending a relationship.
  • Summary: A seven-month relationship ended after the boyfriend threw the girlfriend out for sending a poop sticker while he was in the bathroom, refusing to explain his anger. The update revealed the boyfriend was insecure because his friends teased him for being ’too manly’ after the girlfriend trash-talked them during a game night, interpreting the sticker as an insult to his masculinity.