1291: Should Self-Harm Scars Be Shareable Memoirs? | Feedback Friday

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• The composition of internet comment sections is disproportionately skewed toward unemployed and privileged men, meaning they do not represent a neutral or democratic consensus on online content.  Copied to clipboard!
• When discussing past self-harm scars with children, the approach should be flexible based on the child's developmental age, prioritizing minimal information initially and framing the story around resilience and healing rather than trauma.  Copied to clipboard!
• Navigating interactions with deeply negative individuals, like the wedding guest 'Amanda,' requires setting firm boundaries, potentially involving others in the conversation, or strategically assigning them responsibilities to shift their focus from criticism to contribution.  Copied to clipboard!
• Protecting the fantasy of the 'lone genius' by resisting collaboration or feedback can be a defense mechanism that ultimately hinders professional success in team environments.  Copied to clipboard!
• When setting boundaries with a difficult colleague like 'Tom,' expect an 'extinction burst' where their negative behavior temporarily escalates as they try to recreate the old dynamic.  Copied to clipboard!
• The intense vulnerability and uncertainty inherent in having children serve as a profound reminder of life's precariousness and the necessity of gratitude for health and safety.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Sponsor Reads and Show Intro

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:00)

• Key Takeaway: Progressive Insurance and American Airlines Business Program offer specific financial and travel benefits.
• Summary: Progressive offers a name-your-price tool to potentially lower insurance bills. The American Airlines Advantage Business Program allows companies to earn miles on business travel booked anywhere with American. Travelers using the program can earn additional loyalty points on top of existing benefits.

Feedback Friday Format Introduction

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:16)

• Key Takeaway: Feedback Friday episodes focus on listener letters, advice, soundbites, and cosmic hypothesizing.
• Summary: Jordan Harbinger hosts Feedback Friday alongside producer Gabriel Mizrahi. The segment format includes sharing stories, taking listener letters, offering advice, and playing soundbites. The show’s broader mission is decoding wisdom from fascinating people into practical advice.

Internet Comment Section Bias

Copied to clipboard!

(00:02:31)

• Key Takeaway: Internet comment sections are not neutral forums; they disproportionately feature unemployed, privileged men who are more comfortable voicing public opinions.
• Summary: Linguist Adam Alexik suggests that comment sections skew toward unemployed men due to time availability and socialization patterns. Women are socialized to speak up less online and face greater risks of harassment. Treating comments as democratic consensus is flawed because the visible comments are heavily biased by who participates and by algorithms.

Handling Self-Harm Scar Questions

Copied to clipboard!

(00:05:37)

• Key Takeaway: When addressing self-harm scars with children, lead with minimal information, follow the child’s lead with follow-up questions, and frame the story around resilience and learning coping mechanisms.
• Summary: Dr. Aaron Margolis advises that navigating scar questions depends on the asker’s developmental age and relationship with the questioner. For young children, a simple ‘I got hurt, but I’m healed now’ may suffice. When speaking to one’s own future child, frame the past self-harm as a time when you were upset, got help, and learned better coping skills, ensuring they do not feel an emotional burden.

Managing Negative Wedding Guest

Copied to clipboard!

(00:17:34)

• Key Takeaway: A persistently negative guest who complains about a destination wedding should be addressed directly about the impact of their attitude before the event, or offered a graceful exit from the invitation.
• Summary: The guest, Amanda, assumed she was invited to the Dominican Republic wedding and immediately complained about the expense and selfishness of destination weddings. The hosts suggest either having a direct conversation about how her negativity is hurtful or offering her a graceful way out by stating attendance is not mandatory. An alternative manipulative tactic is assigning her a wedding job, like managing gifts, to channel her need for importance constructively.

Dealing with High-Performer Feedback Resistance

Copied to clipboard!

(00:38:09)

• Key Takeaway: A partner who reacts to professional feedback with anger and lashing out is likely protecting a fragile ego or the identity of being a ’lone genius,’ requiring firm boundaries from colleagues.
• Summary: The partner, Tom, reacts to notes by ranting about management, turning the writer into an emotional dumping ground for both Tom and the boss. This behavior often stems from viewing feedback as a personal, narcissistic wound rather than a technical critique. In a corporate setting, playing well with others and processing feedback is a non-negotiable part of the job, regardless of individual talent.

Defending Lone Genius Fantasy

Copied to clipboard!

(00:46:24)

• Key Takeaway: Admitting the need for collaboration feels like a wound because it necessitates admitting one cannot succeed alone.
• Summary: Protecting the role of a ‘dream team’ often involves staving off external notes, which reinforces the fantasy that one does not need others for their best work. In corporate environments, especially client-facing roles, collaboration is mandatory, making genius exemptions unrealistic. A brilliant writer might be able to tell a publisher off, but an employee cannot dismiss SVPs and account managers.

Managing Bad Feedback and Tom

Copied to clipboard!

(00:47:17)

• Key Takeaway: Coping with bad feedback requires recognizing that sometimes feedback genuinely worsens the work, often prioritizing client management over objective quality.
• Summary: While feedback can aim to improve work, sometimes it introduces bad ideas or is primarily about managing the client’s perception. The friend in the scenario is a high-functioning peacemaker, likely due to early life experiences developing diplomatic skills. This skill set, while useful, places an unasked-for responsibility on them to mediate between ‘Tom’ and higher-ups.

Setting Boundaries with Tom

Copied to clipboard!

(00:48:52)

• Key Takeaway: Boundary setting involves validating Tom’s annoyance briefly (e.g., 10 minutes) before pivoting to action, or directly stating that validating his meltdown is not sustainable.
• Summary: Option one for dealing with Tom is setting a boundary: allow a short time to complain, then pivot to working on the notes, neither indulging nor shutting him down. If he pushes, option two involves stating clearly that you do not share his view on the notes and must conserve energy for the required work. This shift communicates that the friend is no longer the emotional babysitter or punching bag.

Extinction Burst Warning

Copied to clipboard!

(00:50:07)

• Key Takeaway: When changing an established dynamic by setting boundaries, expect an ’extinction burst’ where the other party reacts more strongly to recreate the old pattern.
• Summary: When the friend confronts Tom about his behavior, Tom might react with anger, resentment, or sulking, which is a predictable reaction to boundary enforcement. This temporary worsening of behavior is known as an extinction burst, similar to a child throwing a bigger tantrum when a parent refuses to give in. Recognizing this burst as a sign of being on the right track is crucial for maintaining the new boundary.

Direct Boundary Conversation

Copied to clipboard!

(01:07:24)

• Key Takeaway: A direct approach involves taking Tom out to dinner to acknowledge the shared frustration with feedback while firmly establishing that managing his reaction is his responsibility, not yours.
• Summary: A direct option involves acknowledging that while feedback is annoying, it is part of the business, and Tom’s talent might make it harder to accept. The friend can offer to be a sounding board only up to a point, asking Tom to explain why the feedback causes such distress. If Tom refuses to engage after several months, the friend should eventually ask the boss to address the attitude problem directly with Tom.

Gabe’s Nephew’s Birth Story

Copied to clipboard!

(00:56:21)

• Key Takeaway: The stressful, complicated birth of Gabe’s nephew, involving a C-section against the original plan, highlighted the precarious nature of life and the importance of gratitude.
• Summary: Gabe’s sister, Zara, experienced a textbook pregnancy that turned complicated, leading to a C-section after a long, difficult labor where a doctor unsettlingly stated, ‘I’m not wild about your baby.’ Despite the scare, the baby and mother are now home and healthy, reinforcing the lesson that life’s uncertainties exist alongside joy. The experience inspired awe for parents who courageously confront the uncontrollable risks involved in having children.