The Toast

You're A TRAY-OR: Friday, February 27th, 2026

February 27, 2026

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts celebrated the Friday episode of The Toast by having Jackie Oshry on as a guest, where they discussed potential new Instagram bios for her. 
  • The hosts expressed disappointment with the immediate release of *The Traitors* reunion following the finale, feeling it diminished the drama and psychological intensity of the main show. 
  • The recent news that Netflix backed out of the Warner Bros. bidding leaves Paramount as the likely winner to acquire Warner Brothers Discovery, signaling a major shift in the streaming wars. 
  • The hosts view the Actor Awards presented by SAG-AFTRA as a highly respected, accessible, and fun award show, especially due to its live Netflix broadcast and host Kristen Bell. 
  • The Traitors finale was emotionally devastating for the hosts, who felt Maura's repeated poor decisions led directly to Rob's strategic win, making the game feel pointless for the faithfuls. 
  • The hosts heavily criticized the perceived double standard in how the entertainment industry and media treated Colton Underwood's past actions versus the public backlash faced by Sierra, noting the inconsistency in granting grace for scandals. 

Segments

Podcast Intro and Bio Chat
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Claudia Oshry suggested Jackie Oshry adopt the Instagram bio ‘mom of three, mother to many’.
  • Summary: The hosts opened the Friday episode of The Toast by welcoming listeners and introducing Jackie Oshry as a guest. They spent time brainstorming a new, fitting Instagram bio for Jackie, moving from ‘Gen Z’s big sister’ to a maternal figure. Jackie also mentioned her past struggle in finalizing her own bio, which ultimately quoted her favorite artist, Chapel Rohn.
Pug Caso Talent Recognition
Copied to clipboard!
(00:02:17)
  • Key Takeaway: Philip Phillips, performing anonymously as ‘Pug Caso,’ delivered an amazing Spice Girls cover, earning respect for his talent.
  • Summary: The hosts praised an impressive cover performance by ‘Pug Caso,’ later confirming the singer was Philip Phillips. They reaffirmed the core tenet of The Toast that talent ultimately reigns supreme. They expressed excitement about potentially having Philip Phillips on the show in the future.
The Traitors Finale Reunion Critique
Copied to clipboard!
(00:02:58)
  • Key Takeaway: The immediate release of The Traitors reunion after the finale made the dramatic show feel unserious and anticlimactic.
  • Summary: The hosts agreed that The Traitors reunion should have been released later, perhaps the following week, to maintain the dramatic tension built during the season. They felt the reunion’s immediate drop deflated the psychological intensity of the game, making the investment feel silly. They contrasted this with Love Island’s delayed reunion, noting that key contestants like Johnny and Tara missed the Traitors reunion due to its timing.
Andy Cohen Reunion Hosting Art
Copied to clipboard!
(00:04:41)
  • Key Takeaway: Andy Cohen is considered the unmatched master of hosting reunions due to his ability to balance confrontation with affability and seniority.
  • Summary: The hosts praised Andy Cohen’s unique talent for hosting reunions, noting that no one else seems capable of achieving the same smooth execution. They believe this skill requires having the ‘balls’ to ask tough questions combined with the seniority to be taken seriously. They felt the Traitors reunion lacked this necessary structure, contrasting it with the quality seen in Real Housewives reunions.
Queenie and Weenie Preview
Copied to clipboard!
(00:06:20)
  • Key Takeaway: Jackie Oshry announced her ‘Queenie’ for the week would be a concept, specifically ‘air rights,’ while her ‘Weenie’ would be someone in the room.
  • Summary: The hosts transitioned to the ‘Queenie and Weenie of the Week’ segment, noting the large number of stories to cover. Jackie teased that her Queenie would be a concept, similar to the previously discussed topic of air rights, which she promised to explain. Claudia humorously suggested her Weenie would be someone physically present in the room.
Mahjong and Date Night Recap
Copied to clipboard!
(00:07:50)
  • Key Takeaway: Despite being exhausted, the hosts prioritized their date night, which resulted in a quick, delicious meal and a memorable eavesdropped argument about real estate.
  • Summary: The hosts shared that they played Mahjong intensely until dawn the previous night, with both feeling successful in their gameplay. Jackie recounted her date night, which she almost canceled due to fatigue but ultimately enjoyed because the restaurant offered fast service. While waiting for valet, she overheard an older couple having a vicious, whispered fight about real estate, which she found highly entertaining.
Ballerina Farm Victimhood Critique
Copied to clipboard!
(00:11:25)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts criticized the narrative portraying Ballerina Farm’s founder as a perpetual victim, asserting that growing up and making life changes is normal for mothers.
  • Summary: The hosts reacted to a scathing TikTok exposé about Ballerina Farm, focusing on the founder’s early blog posts where she expressed feeling like a ‘cow and a counter cleaner.’ They argued that this feeling is a common part of early motherhood, not a unique tragedy of having to give up a dream like ballet. They agreed that the public needs to stop viewing her as a victim when she has agency over her adult life.
Dream Compound Dwelling Wishlist
Copied to clipboard!
(00:13:13)
  • Key Takeaway: If building a compound, the hosts would prioritize a state-of-the-art podcast studio, a test kitchen for Ben, and a dedicated game mansion, including a specific room for Mahjong.
  • Summary: Inspired by Ballerina Farm having a ballet studio on her compound, the hosts listed their desired dwellings for a shared compound. These included a podcast studio, a music recording studio, and a test kitchen for Ben. They specifically called for a separate ‘game mansion’ to house various games, ensuring a dedicated room for Mahjong.
Gift Giving Grace and Lists
Copied to clipboard!
(00:14:52)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts advocate for implementing gift lists for their future birthdays and children’s parties, preferring donations or simply attendance over receiving unwanted material items.
  • Summary: The hosts agreed that they do not want more ‘crap’ in their homes, noting that many kids’ party gifts are low-quality items. They expressed a desire to be extended karmic grace if they ever forget a gift for a child’s party, as they often don’t notice when gifts are absent. They praised invitations that explicitly request no gifts or suggest donations to charity instead.
Biz News: Paramount Acquires WBD
Copied to clipboard!
(00:20:14)
  • Key Takeaway: Paramount is set to win the bid for Warner Brothers Discovery after Netflix officially withdrew, citing the acquisition was not a ‘must-have at any price.’
  • Summary: Netflix’s CEO stated that acquiring the major studio was only desirable at the right price, leading them to bow out as Paramount increased its bid into the hundreds of billions. This move solidifies Paramount as the last man standing to acquire HBO/Warner Brothers Discovery. The hosts noted that Netflix had prematurely celebrated the potential acquisition via email to subscribers.
Pink Denies Breakup Rumors
Copied to clipboard!
(00:26:14)
  • Key Takeaway: Pink publicly denied separation rumors from Carey Hart in a video, humorously questioning why Us Weekly reported the fake news before informing her children.
  • Summary: Pink addressed a Us Weekly report claiming she and her husband were separating by releasing a video stating she was unaware of the split. She also used the opportunity to point out her recent Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nomination as real news worthy of coverage. The hosts criticized the publication for reporting unconfirmed news that required a public correction.
Rihanna New Music Tease
Copied to clipboard!
(00:31:26)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts refuse to get excited about Rihanna teasing new music, believing she is unlikely to release a full album due to the impossible hype level.
  • Summary: The hosts expressed fatigue over annual rumors of Rihanna recording new music, stating they are refusing to be bamboozled by studio teases. They suggested she is likely only recording a low-lift feature or a song for an animated movie, as any full album would struggle to meet the massive cultural hype. They contrasted her position with Lady Gaga, whose art is deeply personal and subject to intense scrutiny.
Lana Del Rey Ex on The Bachelorette
Copied to clipboard!
(00:36:34)
  • Key Takeaway: Lana Del Rey’s ex-fiancé, Clayton Echard, is a contestant on Taylor Frankie Paul’s season of The Bachelorette, leading the hosts to label him a fame-chaser.
  • Summary: The hosts learned that Clayton Echard, previously engaged to Lana Del Rey, is now appearing on The Bachelorette. They compared him to Max Ehrich, suggesting he is obsessed with dating successful women for clout, noting that a truly famous person wouldn’t need to go on the show. The hosts agreed that if they were Taylor Frankie Paul, they would send him home immediately upon learning this history.
Actor Awards Rebrand on Netflix
Copied to clipboard!
(00:40:48)
  • Key Takeaway: The SAG Awards have been rebranded as ‘The Actor Awards,’ streaming live on Netflix with a red carpet themed around 1920s/30s Old Hollywood glamour.
  • Summary: The SAG Awards have been rebranded to ‘The Actor Awards,’ streaming exclusively on Netflix this Sunday, featuring a red carpet hosted by Scott Evans and Paige DeSorbo. Kristen Bell was named the host, a choice praised for her high Q score and likability among peers. The event is known for emotional speeches and potential cast reunions, making it highly respected within the industry.
Actor Awards Details
Copied to clipboard!
(00:42:34)
  • Key Takeaway: The Actor Awards are uniquely named after the statue itself, the ‘Actor,’ and are highly respected by industry peers.
  • Summary: The award show is known for iconic moments and emotional speeches, and industry members take receiving an Actor Award seriously because it is voted on by peers. Harrison Ford is receiving the Lifetime Achievement Award, having starred in the impactful film Morning Glory. The event is streaming live on Netflix, hosted by Kristen Bell, and viewers can use an interactive bingo card from tadum.com.
The Traitors Finale Recap
Copied to clipboard!
(00:46:00)
  • Key Takeaway: Rob won The Traitors after Maura failed to banish the known traitor Eric at the first roundtable, leading to Maura’s devastating realization.
  • Summary: Rob won the $220,800 prize because Maura did not vote with Tara and Johnny to eliminate Eric early on, despite knowing Eric was a traitor. The hosts found Maura’s unwavering trust in Rob heartbreaking to watch, noting the light drained from her eyes when he revealed his role. Rob’s strategic move to banish Eric, even though Eric was a traitor, was seen as necessary gameplay to secure his win.
Post-Finale Fallout and Colton
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:28)
  • Key Takeaway: The reunion felt anticlimactic and jokey compared to the high-stakes finale, and the hosts criticized the media’s excessive grace toward Colton Underwood.
  • Summary: The reunion failed to address the finale’s emotional weight, feeling too lighthearted, which made the hosts question the show’s overall seriousness. The hosts strongly condemned the favorable Vanity Fair profile of Colton Underwood, contrasting the protection he received with the harsh treatment Sierra faced for lesser offenses. They argued that Colton’s actions warranted more serious accountability than simply being vague about his past.
Queenie and Weenie Awards
Copied to clipboard!
(01:02:08)
  • Key Takeaway: The ‘Queenie of the Week’ was awarded to the concept of the ‘Kia Asylum,’ a meme describing pop stars struggling to maintain mainstream success.
  • Summary: The Kia Asylum is a concept detailing pop artists who have had success but cannot sustain it, with examples including Bibi Rexa (desperately trying to escape) and Sabrina Carpenter (a major escapee). The men’s ward includes artists like Khalid and Conan Gray, while Tate McRae is noted for having strong TikTok presence but lacking cultural penetration. The Weenie of the Week was given to Ben for forgetting to buy flowers for his wife on Valentine’s Day.