The Toast

The Hairspray Rabbit Hole: Thursday, February 19th, 2026

February 19, 2026

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The hosts are currently obsessed with and critically analyzing Ryan Murphy's series about John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bassett, noting the acting is poor but the subject matter is inherently interesting, while also observing the apparent erasure of Carol Radzwell. 
  • The hosts discussed the ongoing marital issues between *Summer House*'s Kyle and Amanda, concluding that their relationship is sad to watch as they have evolved past each other and are not well-matched. 
  • Ex-Prince Andrew was arrested on his 66th birthday for misconduct in public office (related to forwarding trade documents to Jeffrey Epstein), a technicality that King Charles's statement supports by emphasizing that the law must take its course. 
  • Amanda Seyfried admitted her Executive Producer credit on 'The Housemaid' was a vanity credit negotiated by her agent, as she only acted in the film and did not contribute to its production. 
  • Sophie Turner and Kit Harington found it awkward to film romantic scenes in their new horror movie, 'The Dreadful,' because they are so strongly associated with playing siblings, Sansa and Jon Stark, on 'Game of Thrones.' 
  • The hosts briefly discussed the career 'curse' associated with being major cast members of 'Game of Thrones,' noting that many actors struggle to escape their iconic roles, while others like Peter Dinklage were already established. 

Segments

JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bassett Show
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:03)
  • Key Takeaway: Ryan Murphy’s JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bassett series features corny acting but is compelling due to the inherently interesting historical figures and chic 1990s New York setting.
  • Summary: The hosts are watching the Ryan Murphy series about John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bassett, finding the acting poor but the story captivating. They noted that the show starts at the end of the couple’s story before flashing back in time. The series is also criticized for its Carol Radzwell erasure, suggesting Ryan Murphy holds a personal grievance against her.
Kennedy Family Lore Deep Dive
Copied to clipboard!
(00:04:38)
  • Key Takeaway: The Kennedy family tree is complex, involving figures like Arnold Schwarzenegger’s wife (Maria Shriver) and connections to Cuomo through RFK’s daughter.
  • Summary: A TikTok song about the large Kennedy family lineage helped clarify relationships, including that Arnold Schwarzenegger’s wife is a Kennedy. RFK’s daughter, Mary Perry, married Andrew Cuomo, highlighting the extensive interconnections within the dynasty. The hosts also noted that Carolyn Bassett was plucked from obscurity, working at a mall before meeting JFK Jr.
Summer House Couple Analysis
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:51)
  • Key Takeaway: Kyle and Amanda from Summer House are in a painful, stagnant relationship where Amanda has evolved past Kyle, making their continued effort to stay together seem futile.
  • Summary: The hosts find watching Kyle and Amanda fighting uncomfortable because they are clearly sad and alone in the relationship, despite Amanda professing love. They argue that Kyle has been upfront about who he is for years, and Amanda has evolved past him, suggesting they should separate rather than work through issues.
Keith Urban vs. Paul Salem
Copied to clipboard!
(00:11:37)
  • Key Takeaway: The hosts are staunch Keith Urban supporters, rooting for him in a hypothetical duel against Nicole Kidman’s new partner, Paul Salem.
  • Summary: The hosts declared themselves a ‘Keith Urban first show,’ acknowledging both his and Nicole Kidman’s significant cultural impacts. They expressed hope that Nicole and Keith might reconcile, even though they find it hard to imagine couples who divorce getting back together, citing Kim and Kanye as another example.
Prince Andrew Arrest and Royal Response
Copied to clipboard!
(00:25:56)
  • Key Takeaway: Ex-Prince Andrew was arrested on his birthday for misconduct in public office (forwarding confidential trade documents to Epstein), leading King Charles to issue a statement confirming the law must take its course.
  • Summary: Prince Andrew’s arrest was based on a technicality, similar to Al Capone being charged with tax evasion rather than his primary crimes. King Charles’s statement was notably detached, emphasizing support for the investigation and stating clearly that the law must proceed without royal interference.
Mormon Wives Season 4 Trailer News
Copied to clipboard!
(00:31:31)
  • Key Takeaway: The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 4 trailer confirms Harry Jowsey’s guest appearance, potentially as Taylor’s date, while the hosts speculate on Whitney’s future after her success in Chicago.
  • Summary: Harry Jowsey’s appearance is framed as a chaotic pairing with Taylor, which the hosts jokingly suggest might neutralize both of their toxic energies. The hosts are concerned about Whitney’s career trajectory now that she has achieved success outside the show’s engine, though she confirmed she is extending her run as Roxy Hart in Chicago.
Leighton Meester/Ariana Grande Exchange
Copied to clipboard!
(00:39:11)
  • Key Takeaway: Leighton Meester clarified that her reaction to Ariana Grande at the Critics’ Choice Awards was an unintentional echo of what she thought Ariana said (‘Wow, wow, wow’), not a condescending mockery.
  • Summary: Leighton Meester explained on the Pod Crush podcast that she simply repeated what she thought she heard from Ariana Grande in a split-second exchange. She later tried to explain the misunderstanding to Ariana by jokingly blaming her reaction on being old, which diffused the situation.
Leighton Relationship Structure
Copied to clipboard!
(00:43:16)
  • Key Takeaway: The speaker prefers maintaining separate, distinct relationships with ‘Blair’ and ‘Leighton,’ viewing them as different connections, similar to how one relates to cousins.
  • Summary: The speaker articulated a preference for compartmentalizing relationships, specifically distinguishing between ‘Blair’ and ‘Leighton.’ This structure involves having a close relationship with Blair and a separate one with Leighton. This approach extends to familial relationships, recognizing different tiers like cousins.
Booking.com Advertisement Read
Copied to clipboard!
(00:43:39)
  • Key Takeaway: Booking.com offers a wide array of lodging options, including house rentals necessary for families needing specific amenities like kitchens and refrigerators.
  • Summary: Booking.com provides an extensive selection of hotels and vacation rentals across the U.S., catering to diverse needs, even for picky travelers. The speaker noted a personal shift toward needing house rentals for trips due to requirements like a kitchen for preparing meals or a fridge for storing breast milk. The service is accessible via their website (booking.com) and an app.
Rocket Money Advertisement Read
Copied to clipboard!
(00:44:48)
  • Key Takeaway: Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps users find and cancel unwanted subscriptions, monitor spending, and lower bills to grow savings.
  • Summary: The app’s primary function highlighted is identifying and canceling forgotten subscriptions, such as streaming services or subscription boxes like BarkBox. Beyond subscription management, Rocket Money offers premium features for tracking spending, customizing categories, and setting up automated savings goals. Users can join at rocketmoney.com/toast for assistance in reaching financial goals faster.
Ollie Pet Food Advertisement
Copied to clipboard!
(00:46:30)
  • Key Takeaway: Ollie provides fresh, human-grade dog food meals crafted by vet nutritionists using high-quality ingredients, tailored to individual dog needs.
  • Summary: Ollie caters to all levels of dog ownership, emphasizing that the best treatment for a dog is through quality food. The meals are human-grade, backed by veterinary nutritionists, and designed to appeal even to picky eaters like Romeo, who previously refused standard food. The service offers tailored, perfectly portioned meal plans delivered in mess-free packaging, with a 60% discount on the welcome kit using code Toast at Ollie.com/toast.
Roebuck Jogger Set Advertisement
Copied to clipboard!
(00:48:09)
  • Key Takeaway: Roebuck’s tailored jogger sets are presented as a stylish, warm layering essential for navigating cold weather without sacrificing a put-together appearance.
  • Summary: Roebuck launched new colors (ivory, bright green, navy) for their jogger sets, which solve the problem of layering comfortably in cold climates. The joggers are noted for being soft and comfortable without appearing baggy, and the hoodie provides a tailored second layer, unlike typical unkempt jogger sets. Listeners can use code Toast at roback.com for 20% off their first order through the end of the week.
Amanda Seyfried Producer Credit
Copied to clipboard!
(00:49:31)
  • Key Takeaway: Amanda Seyfried was unaware she was listed as an Executive Producer on ‘The Housemaid’ until three weeks into filming, calling it a vanity credit.
  • Summary: Seyfried revealed on the Graham Norton show that her agent negotiated the producer title, which she only discovered via the call sheet, stating she did not contribute to the movie beyond acting. The hosts contrasted this with actors like Margot Robbie, who intensely develop projects, noting that vanity credits often exist primarily to increase financial earnings if the film succeeds. Transparency about such credits is appreciated, though it can minimize the work of those who genuinely take on creative production roles.
Sophie Turner and Kit Harington Kissing
Copied to clipboard!
(00:52:47)
  • Key Takeaway: Sophie Turner and Kit Harington gagged after kissing on screen in their new horror movie, ‘The Dreadful,’ due to their established history playing siblings on ‘Game of Thrones.’
  • Summary: The actors, who played Sansa and Jon Stark, found the on-screen romance difficult because they developed a sibling-like bond during their time on the show. Turner previously joked about apologizing to fans for the weirdness of playing lovers with her former on-screen brother. The hosts noted that many ‘Game of Thrones’ actors struggle to escape their roles, though Turner has successfully moved into other projects.
Game of Thrones Legacy and Romance
Copied to clipboard!
(00:58:28)
  • Key Takeaway: The prevalence of incestuous relationships in ‘Game of Thrones’ (Cersei/Jaime, Daenerys/Jon) normalized cousin relationships, making Sansa and Jon’s cousin status a non-issue in that context.
  • Summary: The discussion concluded that incest was common in the show’s romantic dynamics, making the cousin relationship between Sansa and Jon Stark insignificant by comparison. Romantically, John went North of the Wall, and Sansa became the Queen in the North, remaining single, which the hosts felt was a potential plot hole regarding the continuation of the Stark line.