Lore

Legends 65: Twin Spirits

October 27, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The foundation of the Twin Cities, Minneapolis and St. Paul, lies on the sacred Dakota land of Bedugte, the center of their world, which was later developed despite its spiritual significance. 
  • The historical rivalry between Minneapolis and St. Paul, rooted in differing demographics and political leanings, manifested in extreme measures like census fraud and organized crime disputes, ultimately leading to a shared focus on baseball as an outlet for animosity. 
  • The Twin Cities are saturated with supernatural lore, featuring haunted locations like the First Avenue nightclub and the Wabashaw Street Caves in St. Paul, alongside the Palmer House Hotel in Sauk Center, illustrating a deep, lingering connection between the land and its inhabitants, both living and deceased. 
  • Recent recognition of the Dakota's sacred space near the confluence of the rivers in 2025 signals a potential reconciliation and honoring of the land's original stewards, perhaps offering peace to the many lingering spirits. 

Segments

Dakota Creation Myth & Sacred Ground
Copied to clipboard!
(00:01:04)
  • Key Takeaway: Bedugte, the Dakota creation site at the confluence of the Minnesota and Mississippi rivers, is considered the Earth’s most sacred point.
  • Summary: The Dakota creation myth describes star people tumbling from the Milky Way and forming the first man and woman from the mud at Bedugte. This location, meaning ’the place where waters meet,’ is central to Dakota cosmology. History transformed this sacred ground into the foundation for Minneapolis and St. Paul.
Founding and Rivalry of Twin Cities
Copied to clipboard!
(00:03:04)
  • Key Takeaway: St. Paul originated as the less respectable ‘Pigs Eye’ settlement, while Minneapolis was named more formally, leading to a sharp, identity-based rivalry.
  • Summary: Pigs Eye was renamed St. Paul, while Minneapolis was named using Dakota and Greek roots for ‘water city.’ St. Paul became home to fur traders and Democrats, contrasting with Minneapolis’s identity as a city of millers and Republicans. This foundational difference fueled a bitter rivalry, exemplified by the cheating during the 1890 U.S. Census.
Gangster Era and Baseball Rivalry
Copied to clipboard!
(00:06:27)
  • Key Takeaway: St. Paul became a ‘gangster’s paradise’ under a corrupt police chief, inadvertently pushing crime into Minneapolis, which was later channeled into intense baseball competition.
  • Summary: St. Paul’s crooked police chief allowed mobsters to operate there if they paid bribes and kept crimes outside city limits, causing Minneapolis to suffer the resulting criminal activity. The cities channeled their intense animosity into minor league baseball matchups, which often escalated into large fights.
Haunted First Avenue Nightclub
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:30)
  • Key Takeaway: First Avenue in Minneapolis is haunted by multiple entities, most notably a mournful woman in a green army jacket who allegedly died by suicide after learning her soldier husband was killed in battle.
  • Summary: First Avenue, a venue famous for Prince, hosts several ghosts, including a poltergeist named Flippy and the notorious woman in the green jacket. This woman is seen gliding or dancing, sometimes missing her legs, and is tied to the building’s history as a bus depot during wartime.
Hauntings at St. Paul’s Fitzgerald Theater
Copied to clipboard!
(00:11:48)
  • Key Takeaway: The Fitzgerald Theater in St. Paul is haunted by ‘vaudeville Veronica,’ a singer whose melodies echo, and ‘Ben,’ a deceased stagehand who acts as a trickster.
  • Summary: Veronica’s spectral singing is heard in the theater, often stopping when investigated. Ben, a former stagehand who froze to death after passing out drunk, is known for moving tools and potentially causing dangerous structural incidents, such as a plaster collapse.
Wabashaw Street Caves History and Ghosts
Copied to clipboard!
(00:13:35)
  • Key Takeaway: The Wabashaw Street Caves, originally silica mines, served as a mushroom farm and a notorious speakeasy frequented by gangsters like John Dillinger before becoming a modern nightclub venue.
  • Summary: The caves were hand-dug mines that became the nation’s largest mushroom farm before Prohibition turned them into a speakeasy where corrupt police allegedly covered up a gangland murder. Regular spirits include well-dressed strangers, a man in a Panama hat, and a sorrowful woman in white.
Wabashaw Caves Fatal Hazards
Copied to clipboard!
(00:18:51)
  • Key Takeaway: The Wabashaw Street Caves contain debris from the 1965 Mississippi River flood, and rule-breaking exploration has led to multiple recorded deaths from cave-ins and carbon monoxide poisoning.
  • Summary: Work crews funneled wreckage from the 1965 flood into off-limits sections of the caves, where explorers sometimes build fires. The heat weakens the ceiling, causing cave-ins, and releases deadly carbon monoxide, resulting in several recorded fatalities since the 1980s.
Spiritual Significance and Return
Copied to clipboard!
(00:20:34)
  • Key Takeaway: The Dakota belief in the land’s special energy binding spirits may explain the density of hauntings, which is now being balanced by the return of a large Indigenous community.
  • Summary: The concentration of spirits might be due to the unique energy of the confluence point where the Dakota believe creation began. In a positive historical correction, Congress and Minneapolis recognized a spiritual spot near the confluence as community space in 2025.
Haunted Palmer House Hotel
Copied to clipboard!
(00:26:06)
  • Key Takeaway: The Palmer House Hotel in Sauk Center, despite lacking records of major tragedies, is intensely haunted, possibly by the spirit of its former night clerk, author Sinclair Lewis.
  • Summary: Guests report soaked luggage, phantom children, flickering lights, and unseen touches in the Palmer House, which opened in 1901 as a modern marvel. Sinclair Lewis, who satirized the town in his famous novel Main Street, is believed to linger there, perhaps drawn back by the place that shaped his imagination.
Show Credits and Support
Copied to clipboard!
(00:30:01)
  • Key Takeaway: Ad-free versions of Lore Legends are available via Apple Podcasts and Patreon, which also grant access to merchandise discounts and bonus ’lore bites’ episodes.
  • Summary: The episode was produced by Aaron Mankey, with writing by Andrew Kelleher and research by Cassandra Day Alba. Listeners can support the show and avoid ads by subscribing to the paid version on Apple Podcasts or Patreon. Further information on the book series and TV adaptation is available at lorepodcast.com.