The noise that isn't there

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• Tinnitus, which affects almost 15% of adults, is often caused by 'hidden hearing loss'—damage to auditory nerve fibers that respond to loud sounds, which standard hearing tests fail to detect.  Copied to clipboard!
• The phantom sound of tinnitus is generated in the central nervous system, where the brain overcompensates for missing auditory input by turning up the volume, similar to phantom limb pain.  Copied to clipboard!
• For severe tinnitus sufferers, the condition can become a 'whole brain problem' where hyperactivity spills over and recruits other brain networks responsible for mood, concentration, and emotion, which is why therapies like CBT can help manage the debilitating effects.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Introduction to Tinnitus Mystery

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:15)

• Key Takeaway: The Short Wave episode features a segment from Vox’s Unexplainable series, ‘The Sound Barrier,’ focusing on tinnitus, a persistent sound perceived by nearly 15% of adults.
• Summary: The episode introduces tinnitus as a scientific mystery where individuals perceive ringing sounds that originate internally, affecting a significant portion of the adult population. Researchers are only beginning to understand the underlying causes of this condition. The segment serves as an introduction to the topic before presenting the main piece from Unexplainable.

Listener’s Experience with Tinnitus

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:10)

• Key Takeaway: Severe tinnitus can manifest as different intense, persistent sounds in each ear and severely impact daily life, leading to job loss, social isolation, and sleep deprivation.
• Summary: A listener named Kelly experienced high-pitched ringing in both ears, initially mistaking it for external noise. Despite seeking medical advice, her hearing tests returned normal results, highlighting the maddening nature of tinnitus when external tests show no issues. The constant noise led Kelly to isolate herself due to lack of sleep and inability to function normally.

Brain Overcompensation Mechanism

Copied to clipboard!

(00:06:09)

• Key Takeaway: Tinnitus often results from the brain overcompensating for reduced auditory information by increasing activity in adjacent neural areas, akin to a climate control system turning up the heat when it gets too cold.
• Summary: Temporary ringing after loud noise exposure is linked to damaged hearing, causing one part of the brain to receive less expected auditory input and leading to hyperactivity in neighboring areas. This overcompensation manifests as a perceived sound that does not exist externally. Chronic tinnitus is when this compensatory ringing fails to subside, drawing a parallel to phantom limb pain.

Limitations of Standard Hearing Tests

Copied to clipboard!

(00:08:00)

• Key Takeaway: Standard audiograms, the gold standard for hearing evaluation, only test for soft sounds and are insensitive to the loss of auditory nerve fibers responsible for loud sound perception, explaining why tinnitus patients often have normal test results.
• Summary: The common hearing test in a soundproof booth only assesses the function of nerve fibers that pick up soft sounds. If the fibers that respond to loud sounds are damaged—a condition called hidden hearing loss—the test will appear normal. This hidden damage to loud-sound fibers is hypothesized to be a root cause of tinnitus, even if the patient struggles in noisy environments like restaurants.

Electrical Response Evidence for Tinnitus

Copied to clipboard!

(00:11:44)

• Key Takeaway: Electrical recordings using electrodes showed that tinnitus patients have reduced firing in the auditory nerve (early peaks) but an abnormally large response in the brainstem (later peaks), indicating the brain is actively turning up the volume to compensate for the input loss.
• Summary: Researchers used electrodes to measure electrical responses to a click sound, observing less firing from the inner ear’s auditory nerve in tinnitus sufferers. Crucially, the brainstem response was larger than expected, demonstrating central nervous system generation of the sound. This electrical signature provides physical evidence of the brain’s hyperactivity that underlies the perceived phantom noise.

Tinnitus Severity and Brain Networks

Copied to clipboard!

(00:16:26)

• Key Takeaway: Severe tinnitus involves a ‘whole brain problem’ where the hyperactivity expands beyond the auditory pathway to incorporate and dysregulate executive control, mood, and emotion networks, unlike mild tinnitus.
• Summary: For individuals with severe tinnitus, the sound perception has expanded to recruit other brain systems, leading to associated issues like depression and inability to concentrate. Therapies like cognitive behavioral therapy can target these recruited brain areas to reduce the debilitating impact, potentially turning a severe disorder into a mild annoyance.

Coping Strategies and Re-engagement

Copied to clipboard!

(00:14:00)

• Key Takeaway: Masking sounds, while sometimes helpful for mild cases, can be counterproductive for severe tinnitus by constantly reminding the patient of the noise, prompting a shift toward re-engaging with real-world sounds.
• Summary: Maskers, which play white or pink noise, are considered a temporary ‘band-aid’ by experts like Stéphane Maison because they can keep the tinnitus top-of-mind. Listener Kelly is now attempting to phase out hearing aids and maskers to actively listen to the world again, even enduring startling sounds like fireworks to retrain her brain to process external auditory information.