What It's Like To Stay Together For the Kids— and the Mortgage Rate

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• The primary motivation for Morgan Dickson and her ex-husband to cohabitate post-divorce is prioritizing the children's stability, with the low 2% mortgage rate acting as a significant financial incentive.  Copied to clipboard!
• Morgan and her ex-husband are navigating their shared living arrangement through strict scheduling and high communication, acknowledging it is a temporary experiment that requires managing personal irritations for the children's benefit.  Copied to clipboard!
• The high cost of renting and restrictive HOA rules in their desirable area made moving out financially unfeasible for Morgan, highlighting the 'lock-in effect' on personal life decisions beyond just selling property.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Introduction and Viral Story Context

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:01)

• Key Takeaway: Morgan Dickson’s viral story involves cohabitating with her ex-husband specifically to retain a 2% mortgage rate, illustrating the real-world impact of the housing market’s ’lock-in effect'.
• Summary: Host Nicole Lapin introduces guest Morgan Dickson, whose story about living with her ex to keep a low mortgage rate gained attention in The Wall Street Journal. The arrangement is framed as an example of the ’lock-in effect,’ where high current rates deter homeowners from selling. The episode promises a deeper dive into the economics of divorce and intertwined financial decisions.

Sponsorship Break: Square

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:18)

• Key Takeaway: Square offers integrated tools for small businesses to manage payments, appointments, and staffing without complex contracts.
• Summary: The first sponsor, Square, is promoted as an essential tool for turning a hobby into a hustle by simplifying business operations. The host shares an anecdote about a vendor successfully using Square to accept card payments at a farmer’s market. Listeners can receive up to $200 off Square Hardware using a specific promotional code.

Sponsorship Break: Chime

Copied to clipboard!

(00:02:19)

• Key Takeaway: Chime offers banking services with no monthly or maintenance fees, early direct deposit access, and fee-free ATM networks.
• Summary: The second sponsor, Chime, is presented as a superior alternative to traditional banks charging monthly fees for minimal services. Benefits include receiving paychecks up to two days early with qualifying direct deposits and eligibility for free overdraft protection up to $200. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank, with services provided by partner banks.

Primary Reasons for Cohabitation

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:30)

• Key Takeaway: The decision to stay together in the home is primarily driven by the children’s best interest, supported by the financial benefit of retaining a low mortgage rate and significant property appreciation.
• Summary: Morgan clarifies that the main reason for the arrangement is to keep both parents accessible for their children daily, minimizing disruption. The financial gain is substantial, as current neighborhood property values have increased by at least 75% since they purchased the home in 2017. They also plan to hold the properties long-term, hoping the appreciated assets benefit their children later.

Logistics of Shared Living

Copied to clipboard!

(00:05:23)

• Key Takeaway: The cohabitating ex-spouses manage sleeping arrangements using a weekly schedule determined by an app, ensuring dedicated private time for each parent with the children.
• Summary: Sleeping arrangements are managed via a weekly schedule, typically alternating three or four nights per person, with the goal of allocating time when one parent has the house entirely to themselves with the kids. An initial attempt to use an Airstream trailer for separate living proved illegal after the viral article prompted a city code inspection. Morgan is now preparing to build her own home on an adjacent lot she owns.

Financial Details of Property Division

Copied to clipboard!

(00:09:23)

• Key Takeaway: The couple purchased their home in 2017 for $265,000, which Zillow now estimates at $5.83 million, illustrating massive equity retention as a key financial driver.
• Summary: The house was bought in 2017 for approximately $265,000, and the current estimated value is significantly higher, with an adjacent vacant lot valued near $440,000. Morgan struggled to find affordable local rentals, with eligible one-bedroom units starting at $1,700, which her current salary could not support, reinforcing the need to stay put.

Handling Shared Assets and Contributions

Copied to clipboard!

(00:12:30)

• Key Takeaway: The divorce settlement was simplified because the couple maintained separate finances before marriage, though Morgan’s inheritance and pension funded renovations on the property Ryan now owns.
• Summary: The couple had few joint assets as they were financially independent before marriage; however, Morgan’s inheritance funded many renovations, and her pension was used to buy the adjacent lot. Morgan emphasizes that the stay-at-home parent role, which she held for five years, holds significant unmonetized value equivalent to hiring a nanny, housekeeper, and cook.

Property Settlement and Future Plans

Copied to clipboard!

(00:15:12)

• Key Takeaway: The settlement divided the adjacent properties, with Ryan retaining the house and Morgan taking the vacant lot next door, where she is actively planning to build her own home.
• Summary: Ryan retained the house, while Morgan received the deed to the adjacent lot where she plans to build, ensuring they remain neighbors for the children’s benefit in the short term. Morgan intends to travel extensively once the children are older, designing her future home with that in mind, but acknowledges the current arrangement is temporary until her build is complete.

Ground Rules and Relationship Status

Copied to clipboard!

(00:16:32)

• Key Takeaway: A key ground rule established was a one-year moratorium on introducing romantic guests to maintain a stable environment for the children.
• Summary: The ex-spouses agreed not to bring romantic guests around for at least a year, and they are not currently dating, maintaining weekly family dinners and activities. Morgan notes that the lack of a clear break makes dating difficult, and she cannot afford to rent an apartment for the year while building due to allocated build funds.

Expense Division and Amicable Divorce

Copied to clipboard!

(00:19:18)

• Key Takeaway: Shared expenses like school fees and groceries are split evenly, while property taxes for her lot are paid separately by Morgan, reflecting a negotiated division of costs.
• Summary: Expenses are divided based on ownership (Morgan pays taxes on her lot) and shared needs (school costs and groceries are split evenly). Their divorce process was notably fast and inexpensive ($4,000 total, split evenly), attributed to their mutual agreement on asset division, including inherited properties, rather than lengthy legal battles.

Societal Judgment and Support

Copied to clipboard!

(00:21:54)

• Key Takeaway: While many supportive parents understand the arrangement, the viral attention brought significant negative judgment, particularly from online comments, which Morgan chose to ignore.
• Summary: Some people were supportive, recognizing similar arrangements, but others judged the situation as ‘crazy,’ especially after the Wall Street Journal publication. Morgan found the arrangement through support groups for separated parents, where she encouraged others considering the same path. The success for the children is evident, as their lives have not changed significantly beyond the parents not sleeping together.

Advice for Similar Arrangements

Copied to clipboard!

(00:24:44)

• Key Takeaway: For couples sharing a home post-separation, the ability to communicate level-headedly during disagreements and viewing the situation as strictly temporary are crucial for success.
• Summary: Morgan stresses that couples must honestly assess their ability to handle conflict without traumatizing the children, as heated moments are inevitable. She advises repeating a reassuring mantra that the situation is temporary and best for the children to maintain strength during difficult times. Her situation is unique because she owns a separate property she will eventually move into.

Career Pivot and Fulfillment

Copied to clipboard!

(00:29:07)

• Key Takeaway: Morgan discovered that being a full-time stay-at-home mother was less fulfilling than she anticipated, driving her desire to return to project-oriented work that creates effective change.
• Summary: Morgan struggled with fulfillment as a stay-at-home mom after leaving a career in healthcare where she enjoyed transforming delivery models. She found energy in co-creating solutions with invested individuals, a feeling missing from full-time caregiving, despite loving her children. Her children’s growing independence has made returning to work and supporting herself feel timely and necessary.

Financial Planning Tip for Separation

Copied to clipboard!

(00:35:16)

• Key Takeaway: The final piece of money advice for separating spouses is to craft a detailed Excel sheet outlining all necessary monthly survival expenses before making major decisions.
• Summary: Morgan advises creating a spreadsheet detailing fixed costs like insurance (home, car), utilities, mortgage, and childcare to establish the minimum monthly income required for survival. This financial clarity helps in navigating the separation process and finding ways to meet that baseline number, even if it means making temporary sacrifices like foregoing personal health insurance.