The Status Game (with Will Storr)

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

• The fundamental human drive, beyond survival and reproduction, is the subconscious need for status, which is a score of our perceived value to the cooperative human community.  Copied to clipboard!
• Life is composed of effectively infinite status games, and individuals constantly seek environments where they can achieve higher relative status, often shifting games as they age or face limitations in others.  Copied to clipboard!
• Attempts to completely escape the status game—such as through isolation (Hikikomori), spiritual detachment (Buddhism), or political ideology (Communism)—have historically proven catastrophic or self-delusional.  Copied to clipboard!

Segments Expand All Collapse All

Introduction and Adam Smith Link

Copied to clipboard!

(00:00:02)

• Key Takeaway: Human desire extends beyond being loved to being ’lovely,’ signifying a need to earn respect and admiration honestly.
• Summary: The podcast begins by welcoming listeners and introducing the guest, Will Storr, and his book, The Status Game. Host Russ Roberts connects the book’s theme to Adam Smith’s insight that humans desire not only to be loved but to be lovely. This desire involves earning respect and admiration from others, even if sometimes self-deception is involved.

Defining Life as Status Game

Copied to clipboard!

(00:01:48)

• Key Takeaway: Subconscious brain processes treat life as a reward space, driven by needs for survival, connection, and status, with status being a profound, non-optional urge.
• Summary: Will Storr explains that while conscious experience is a narrative, the subconscious treats life as a game driven by a reward system. Humans fundamentally seek survival, connection, and status; status is a critical need because, as cooperative apes, we are motivated by signals that we contribute value to the group. Chronic lack of status leads to mental and physical illness.

Liberation from Constant Judgment

Copied to clipboard!

(00:03:51)

• Key Takeaway: The constant, automatic assessment of others and self-assessment of status, termed the ‘status detection system,’ is exhausting, and its temporary removal (like in silent retreats) is profoundly liberating.
• Summary: Russ Roberts describes the liberating experience of a silent meditation retreat where eye contact and recognition were forbidden, highlighting the constant, subconscious judgment people inflict on each other (e.g., judging appearance or status in an elevator). Storr confirms the brain has an always-on ‘status detection system’ that continually assesses relative standing, which is functional but costly.

Status in Cooperative Groups

Copied to clipboard!

(00:06:10)

• Key Takeaway: Human cooperation necessitates status games as a system of incentive and punishment, where higher status historically correlated directly with better access to resources and mates.
• Summary: Humans are highly cooperative, functioning in groups (like armies or teams) that solve existence problems collectively. To make these groups functional, a system of rewards and punishments—the status game—is required. In hunter-gatherer times, usefulness to the tribe directly translated to higher status, leading to better food, safety, and reproductive success.

Status Loss and Association Anxiety

Copied to clipboard!

(00:08:06)

• Key Takeaway: The desire to avoid status loss causes discomfort when associating with those perceived as lower status, illustrating the subconscious nature of status leakage.
• Summary: The flip side of seeking status is avoiding its loss, which can manifest as shame when associating with those deemed unworthy. Storr notes that status ’leaks,’ meaning people seek higher-status company to gain status, but feel uncomfortable around lower-status individuals as status leaks away from them.

Shifting Status Games with Age

Copied to clipboard!

(00:11:32)

• Key Takeaway: Since life involves effectively infinite status games, individuals must strategically choose games where their current attributes (like experience over youth/beauty) allow them to be a ‘bigger fish.’
• Summary: Conversations about aging and concert crowds illustrate that the status games of youth (like beauty) become unwinnable. The liberating understanding is that one can switch to different status games where experience and expertise grant higher standing. Competing in games where one is fated to be low status, like an older person at a CrossFit gym, can be humbling.

Prisoner’s Status Over Freedom

Copied to clipboard!

(00:14:14)

• Key Takeaway: The need for status can be so paramount that an individual will choose a high-status position within a restrictive environment over freedom and love in the outside world.
• Summary: Storr recounts the story of Ben Gunn, a long-serving prisoner who became a high-status ‘prison lawyer’ among inmates. Upon release to a loving home, he suffered a breakdown, stating he was ’nothing’ outside the prison where he was respected. This demonstrated that status respect can outweigh freedom and romantic connection.

Status vs. Power and Incessant Wanting

Copied to clipboard!

(00:35:35)

• Key Takeaway: The desire for status is an insatiable, ratcheting urge that never wears out, unlike the desire for power, which often diminishes due to associated stress and responsibility.
• Summary: Studies suggest that while the desire for power fades, the desire for status is perpetual; people are content being above average but always seek to ratchet up their standing slightly more. Paul McCartney’s late-life insistence on flipping songwriting credits from ‘Lennon McCartney’ to ‘McCartney Lennon’ exemplifies this deeply human, relentless pursuit of status recognition, even at the highest levels of fame.

Status and Political Culture Shifts

Copied to clipboard!

(00:39:31)

• Key Takeaway: The cultural shift in the 1980s toward individualism, exemplified by ‘greed is good’ and naming children to ‘stand out,’ mirrored the Thatcher-Reagan economic project of increasing competition.
• Summary: Storr argues that economic policies promoting competition coincided with a radical change in Western culture, moving from collective focus (‘screw the man’) to individualistic competition (‘greed is good’). Evidence includes a surge in perfectionism rates and a shift in naming children to unusual names, reflecting a cultural mandate to stand out and compete.

Tribalism as Group Status Competition

Copied to clipboard!

(00:51:37)

• Key Takeaway: Tribalism and political outrage are manifestations of group status competition, where groups claim superior ’truth’ and demand adherence to their group’s moral symbols to assert dominance.
• Summary: Group status is a key component of the status game, evidenced by the intense emotional investment in sports teams. Groups often exhibit ‘group narcissism,’ feeling entitled to boast about their contributions, which fuels nationalism. Moral outrage and ‘cancel culture’ are seen as attacks on the status of one’s group by demanding others adopt its specific truths.

Advice: Reduce Moral Sphere

Copied to clipboard!

(00:57:15)

• Key Takeaway: To mitigate stress and aggression caused by constant status competition, individuals should reduce their focus on policing the moral behavior of others and concentrate instead on their own moral conduct.
• Summary: Storr advises reducing one’s ‘moral sphere’ as a reaction to the feverish moral surveillance fueled by social media. This means focusing introspection on one’s own moral behavior rather than obsessing over the perceived moral failings of others. This approach aims to lessen the aggression and stress inherent in status-driven group conflict.