Unexplainable

When talent vanishes overnight

October 20, 2025

Key Takeaways Copied to clipboard!

  • The phenomenon known as the yips, where experts suddenly lose the ability to perform a practiced skill, is characterized by a profound loss of control that athletes describe as distinct from simple choking under pressure. 
  • While historically attributed to psychological factors, the yips may, in some cases, be caused by a physical neurological disorder called focal dystonia, which involves involuntary muscle activation during a specific task. 
  • Former baseball player Rick Ankiel's journey demonstrated that overcoming the yips might require adapting to the unknown rather than forcing a solution, as he found success only after abandoning pitching for outfield, and later, his arm strength returned even when pitching mechanics remained elusive. 

Segments

Introduction to Performance Loss
Copied to clipboard!
(00:00:31)
  • Key Takeaway: The episode premise centers on the sudden, inexplicable loss of highly practiced skills, exemplified by athletes and artists.
  • Summary: The podcast Unexplainable, in the episode “When talent vanishes overnight,” introduces the concept of losing a core, practiced skill without illness or injury. This phenomenon has affected great performers, including gymnast Simone Biles and baseball player Rick Ankiel. Various names exist for this issue, such as the yips, dartitis, and musicians cramp.
Rick Ankiel’s Pitching Collapse
Copied to clipboard!
(00:03:58)
  • Key Takeaway: Rick Ankiel experienced a sudden, catastrophic loss of pitching control during a high-stakes playoff game, marked by wild pitches and muscle locking.
  • Summary: Rick Ankiel, a highly touted prospect, began struggling severely in a postseason game after an initial wild pitch, leading to multiple subsequent wild pitches. His muscles and fingers locked up, causing the ball to exit his hand uncontrollably, as if he forgot how to throw. This event marked the beginning of his struggle with the yips, leading to 35 tortured pitches in one inning.
Choking vs. Loss of Control
Copied to clipboard!
(00:06:53)
  • Key Takeaway: The yips represent a loss of control fundamentally different from typical choking under pressure, where the athlete remains in control.
  • Summary: Sports psychologist Sally Akehurst differentiates the yips from choking, noting that athletes experiencing the yips describe a loss of control beyond mere performance failure. High-level performance relies on automaticity, which is broken when an athlete stops trusting themselves. Consciously trying to regain automaticity, like trying to force sleep, often makes the problem worse.
Ankiel’s Failed Recovery Attempts
Copied to clipboard!
(00:08:56)
  • Key Takeaway: Ankiel’s attempts to consciously fix his mechanics by overanalyzing every throw only exacerbated the problem, even in low-pressure situations.
  • Summary: Rick Ankiel tried to regain control by working harder and consciously focusing on specific mechanics, but these efforts failed, even when playing catch casually. The stigma around the yips caused teammates to avoid discussing the issue, increasing his isolation and obsession. This overanalysis extended to everyday actions, as he questioned basic routines like brushing his hair.
Retirement and Career Pivot
Copied to clipboard!
(00:12:35)
  • Key Takeaway: After years of struggle, Ankiel retired from pitching due to the yips but found redemption by accepting a radical career change to outfield.
  • Summary: Despite psychological management, Ankiel struggled for years until he quit pitching in 2005, feeling like a failure but experiencing immediate relief. His agent subsequently suggested he try playing outfield, a suggestion Ankiel initially dismissed but then felt compelled to pursue after a profound, almost spiritual experience while swinging a bat. He successfully transitioned to the outfield, working his way back to the major leagues over two and a half years.
The Return of Talent and Dystonia Theory
Copied to clipboard!
(00:21:13)
  • Key Takeaway: Ankiel’s successful return as an outfielder, culminating in a home run, suggests the yips might be physiological, as his pitching arm later recovered only when throwing from extreme distances.
  • Summary: Ankiel achieved redemption with a three-run home run as an outfielder, demonstrating that he found a way around the yips by accepting what he couldn’t explain. Later, his pitching arm regained accuracy and strength when throwing from 180 feet away, but he still could not throw strikes from the standard 60-foot pitching mound. Neurologist Steve Frucht explains that this task-specific difference suggests a physiological disorder like focal dystonia, a movement disorder affecting specific motor tasks.
Focal Dystonia and Learning Systems
Copied to clipboard!
(00:25:38)
  • Key Takeaway: Focal dystonia is a neurological movement disorder where involuntary twitches occur only during a specific learned action, offering scientists a unique window into motor learning.
  • Summary: Focal dystonia is characterized by involuntary twitches in one body part only during a specific action, such as writing or playing an instrument, and can be observed via functional MRI showing abnormal brain activation. Practicing more often accelerates the problem in dystonia cases, making rest crucial. Studying this failure in the system may reveal fundamental truths about how talent and complex motor skills are learned and maintained.
Episode Conclusion and Credits
Copied to clipboard!
(00:29:23)
  • Key Takeaway: The episode concludes by emphasizing the profound mystery surrounding how complex skills are learned, suggesting the yips reveal more about normal learning than failure.
  • Summary: The episode credits the production team, including reporter Noam Hasenfeld, and recommends Rick Ankiel’s book, The Phenomenon. Listeners are encouraged to email the show with their thoughts. The final thought posits that the yips reveal how mysterious the process of acquiring talent and automaticity truly is.